At Chidiac & Associates, we provide experienced criminal defence representation to clients facing Public Mischief charges throughout Sydney and New South Wales. We carefully examine what was said or reported, the circumstances in which the representation was made and whether the Prosecution can establish the required elements of the offence.

What is Public Mischief?

The offence is contained in section 547B of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

A person commits Public Mischief where they knowingly make a false representation to a member of the police force that an act has been, or will be, done, or that an event has occurred, or will occur, where the act or event as represented is such that it calls for an investigation by police.

A representation can also be made indirectly. The legislation provides that a person may be deemed to have made a representation to police where they make it to another person and the nature of the representation reasonably requires that person to communicate it to police, and it is subsequently communicated.

Examples of Public Mischief

Allegations may arise where a person is accused of:

• falsely reporting that they have been assaulted;
• falsely reporting that property has been stolen;
• making a false report concerning an alleged criminal incident;
• falsely claiming that an offence has occurred; or
• providing false information that causes police to commence an investigation.

The particular circumstances and content of the alleged representation are critical.

Elements of Public Mischief

To establish an offence under section 547B, the Prosecution must prove the relevant elements beyond reasonable doubt.

1. A Representation Was Made

The Prosecution must establish that the accused made a representation concerning an act or event.

The representation may be made directly to police or, in the circumstances specified by the legislation, to another person who communicates it to police.

2. The Representation Was False

The Prosecution must establish that the representation was false.

A genuine mistake, misunderstanding or inaccurate recollection does not necessarily amount to Public Mischief.

3. The Representation Was Made Knowingly

The Prosecution must establish that the accused knowingly made the false representation.

This requirement can be particularly important where a person has made a statement based upon an honest misunderstanding or incorrect belief.

4. The Matter Called for Police Investigation

The alleged act or event must be of a nature that, if represented as having occurred or being about to occur, would call for an investigation by police.

What Are the Penalties for Public Mischief?

Under section 547B of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), the maximum penalty is:

6 months' imprisonment

or

5 penalty units

or both.

These are the maximum penalties and do not mean that a person convicted of Public Mischief will automatically receive imprisonment.

Public Mischief Penalties at a Glance

‍

Can I Defend a Public Mischief Charge?

Being charged with Public Mischief does not mean that you are guilty. The Prosecution bears the burden of proving the offence beyond reasonable doubt.

Depending upon the circumstances, potential issues may include:

• the representation was not false;
• the accused genuinely believed the representation to be true;
• the accused did not knowingly make a false representation;
• the representation was not made to police or communicated in the manner required by the legislation;
• the alleged event did not call for a police investigation;
• the Prosecution cannot establish who made the representation; or
• the Prosecution evidence is unreliable or inconsistent.

The appropriate defence depends upon the evidence and circumstances of the individual matter.

Evidence in Public Mischief Cases

The Prosecution may rely upon:

• police statements;
• recordings of telephone calls;
• body-worn camera footage;
• CCTV;
• text messages and other communications;
• recordings of interviews;
• witness statements; and
• admissions allegedly made by the accused.

The precise words used, the context in which they were communicated and the accused person's state of knowledge can all be important.

Sentencing for Public Mischief

Where a person is convicted, the court may consider:

• the nature of the false representation;
• the seriousness of the alleged incident;
• the extent of the police investigation generated;
• the resources required by police;
• whether the conduct was planned;
• the offender's criminal history;
• personal circumstances;
• remorse;
• prospects of rehabilitation; and
• whether an early guilty plea was entered.

The court will consider both the circumstances of the offending and the individual circumstances of the offender.

How We Can Help

At Chidiac & Associates, we provide:

• confidential advice about your Public Mischief charge;
• detailed analysis of the Prosecution evidence;
• examination of police statements and recordings;
• assessment of the circumstances in which the representation was made;
• advice concerning potential defences;
• representation at court;
• negotiations with prosecutors where appropriate;
• preparation for defended hearings; and
• sentencing advice and representation.

Our approach is built on thorough preparation, practical advice and strong courtroom advocacy.